Rumpelstiltskin, The Immoral Lessons Of The Fairytale

Rumpelstiltskin is a very famous fairytale.This fairytale is widely known around the world with many variants.It tells a story of a miller’s daughter who was saved by an ugly ogre called Rumpelstiltskin.As I grew up, I noted some disturbing lessons from the story which I thought makes this story inappropriate for young children.

How the story goes

Once there was a miller who had a very lazy daughter.One day the miller lied to the king that his daughter can spin straw into gold.The king locked the girl in a tower and forced her to spin straw into gold in one night.

If on the next morning he didn’t see his gold, he would cut her head.She was crying helplessly when suddenly a crooked little man called Rumpelstiltskin appeared and offered help.The creature can spin straw into gold for her in return for her necklace.The king was so happy when he saw gold in his tower that he ordered the girl to do it again.Rumpelstiltskin agreed to help this second time in return for the girl’s ring.The king was again so happy to see the gold.He locked the girl in larger room and once again ordered her to fill it with gold overnight.If she could do it, the king will marry her.Rumpelstiltskin agreed to help but the girl had nothing to be given to him in return.So Rumpelstiltskin made the girl promise to give him her firstborn child.

The girl agreed, the gold was ready and the king married her and she became queen.When she had her first child, Rumpelstiltskin appeared again to claim the baby.She didn’t want to give him up to him and offered him her wealth instead.Rumpelstiltskin didn’t want money and fortune, but he asked the queen to guess his name in three days.If she succeeded he will leave the child alone.The queen followed Rumpelstiltskin to his home.He sang a song and in one of his songs’ lyrics, he mentioned his name.The queen guessed the name correctly.Rumpelstiltskin was angry as he cannot get the baby and then he vanished.End of the story.


The immoral lessons


First of all why the miller lies to the king? How could he put his own daughter in a dangerous situation? Some versions say that the miller does it because he wants to look important before the king.So he sells his daughter for fame.The king obviously marries the girl because of the gold not out of love.He even threatened to kill her three times if she ever fails to spin the straw into gold.The father doesn’t love the girl the king does not either.Then who really loves the girl? Rumplestiltskin? No.Rumpelstilskin is also an opportunist who is willing to help only in return of something.When the girl no longer has anything valuable to give him, he asked her to promise to give him her firstborn child after she becomes queen.What a poor girl.It looks like everyone wants to take advantage of her.


The girl, on the other hand, has questionable characters too.How could she marry the cruel and greedy man who had imprisoned her, who doesn’t love him, who had threatened to kill her and who only after the gold? Is she afraid or she also after the king’s fortune? She also breaks her oath to Rumpelstilskin, the only creature who comes to the rescue when she was powerless and helpless.


They story is less violent compared to other fairytales but it has very gruesome ending.In the Brother Grimm’s version, after the queen guess his name correctly, Rumpelstiltskin stamps his foot on the ground, the foot gets stuck, he grabs it, tries to pull it and eventually rips himself in half.
 

Article Written by Yovita Siswati


Post Your Comment

Related Articles

  • The Story Of Loro Blonyo – Javanese Traditional Statue

    Loro Blonyo is a miniature of traditional Javanese bridegroom. The statue is a symbol of the God and Goddess of fertility in Javanese culture: Devi (Goddess) Cri and God Sadono. Java is an island, part of the Indonesian archipelago whose society is very rich in customs and traditions.

  • Dark Original Version Of Classic Fairytale: Red Little Riding Hood – The Cannibalism

    Little Red Riding Hood, like any other classic fairy tale, is originated from ancient folklore that had been orally told for centuries from one generation to the next by often illiterate people before being written down. The tale had been considerably changing and subject to numerous adaptations as they spread throughout the world.

  • Cendrawasih: Papua’s Most Beautiful Bird Of Paradise

    Paradisaea bird or the bird of paradise found in Papua, Indonesia and also in New Guinea had long been recognized for its rarely beautiful plumage. Known locally as Cendrawasih, this bird now suffers from illegal hunting and is on the brink of extinction.

    Cendrawasih, is believed by local tribes to have a mystical properties, the tribes believe that the bird is the bird of the gods that come from heaven and because of that the birds will never set foot on ground. Members of the tribes use Cendrawasih feathers to decorate their heads and cloths during cultural feast.

  • Most Notable Unsuccessful Attempts To Kill Hitler From 1943 To 1944

    Between the year of 1943 to 1944, there were still many attempts to assinate Hitler. None was succesful due to various reasons. Here are the unsuccessful assination stories.


    Rudolf von Gersdorff (March 1943)

  • Dark Original Version Of Classic Fairytale: Pinocchio’s Extreme Poverty And Gruesome Death

    This classic Italian story had evolved for centuries since it was first written as a children novel by Carlo Collodi. The original version is far from being beautiful. It is on the contrary a depressing story with a tragic ending.

  • Ancient Roman Graffiti: History On A Piece Of Wall

    Public markings crafted by ancient Roman on their city wall which survived to this day are an important socio cultural heritage. They provide evidence of the daily life of the commoner at that time of Roman Empire.

    History

    The habit to craft letters or images on properties later known as “graffiti” had begun since prehistoric time when our prehistoric ancestor made cave paintings using animal bones and natural pigments to mark territory, record successful hunting expedition, or simply to describe wildlife scene.

  • Most Notorious Psychopaths In History

    Psychopaths are people with chronic immoral behavior who gain satisfaction through antisocial actions. They have uncontrollable aggressive impulses. Psychopathy does not always lead to criminal behavior. However when psychopathic is accompanied with low social cognition, it will usually lead to pathological narcissism. This narcissism drives violence behavior towards others and triggers failure in relationship and in keeping an occupation. A psychopath never feels remorse for their actions

    Albert Hamilton Fish

  • Dark Original Version Of Classic Fairytale: Sleeping Beauty: The Curse, The Rape And The Ogress

    Sleeping Beauty is one of many classic tales that has many twisted versions. The most popular version, the one we are most familiar with is the one written by Brother Grimms in 18th century. The earlier versions are however full of shocking plots and various bizarre endings.

  • Snow White : The Canibal Queen And Necrophiliac Prince

    Snow White is a sweet story of an innocent girl fighting for her life. Do you know that the original version of Snow White fairytale is full of shocking plots?The Grimm’s collection is our only source of the original version of the story as Perrault did not include Snow White in his collection. Grimm made two versions. The first was recorded in 1810 and known as the “peasant version”. In this first version there were no stepmother and prince.

  • Dark Original Version Of Classic Fairytale: The Pied Piper Of Hamelin: What Really Happened To The Children?

    The tale of Pied Piper was based on a true tragic event occurred in the 13th century.  At that time 130 children in the city of Hamelin, Germany, vanished of unknown causes. The grieving parents then created a story that the children had been taken away by a man named Pied Piper. Here the history of this tale began.


    The Original Version